Summary: A classic pizzeria with a fluffy crust.
Matthew's Pizza has been a beloved institution since 1943, serving up its signature fluffy-crusted pizzas to generations of fans. Located in Highlandtown, the restaurant has kept its charm with an old-fashioned dining room, complete with murals of the Italian countryside. Despite debates over the crust's ability to hold heavy toppings, many loyal customers see it as the epitome of what pizza should be. The pizzeria also offers huge salads, spaghetti with homemade sausage or shrimp, bountiful subs, and homemade sorbets. With the Creative Alliance nearby, Matthew's Pizza continues to attract a mix of long-time patrons and new enthusiasts, some of whom prefer to take their favorite pies home frozen to satisfy future cravings. This colorful storefront has become a city landmark, known for both its thin-crust and deep-dish pizzas.